Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts

Monday, October 3, 2011

Age of the Individual (and it's consequences)


We live in the Age of the Individual. Despite claims of expanding communities through computers and social networks, we are becoming a more selfish, self-absorbed society that cares less for the collective good than the good of the individual.

This has severe societal and economic impacts. In 2007-2008 the world watched as the greed of a select group plunged millions of people into unemployment and sent-off economic shockwaves around the world. These shockwaves manifested themselves on the doorsteps of "working class" people through government layoffs of teachers, companies laying off thousands of workers for short-term cost-savings and societal redistribution in Greece. The crisis and the aftermath are both the result of short-term thinking by individuals - both in government and corporations.

The forestry industry is a great parable to modern economics. In the 1970-1980s the forestry industry was clear-cutting itself into extinction. Through government and social pressure, the industry was put on a more sustainable path. This is a lesson the oil industry needs to learn, but also the financial industry.

In 2005-2007 when the mortgage bubble was being inflated by the demand for mortgage-backed securities (MBS), individuals made the decision to set aside their reservations and make money. Mortgage brokers attest to the fact that they processed paperwork they didn't feel comfortable submitting, but it was approved. Why? The mortgage broker wanted the commission, and if it was approved, it no longer was their problem, so why not be greedy? Who was doing the approvals? The person who was going to sell the mortgages to Wall Street for a nice commission, so why not be greedy?

We exist in a world where society is so far removed from our lives. Everything and everyone is so disconnected, the decisions we make are in our individual best interests, not the best interest of our community. Even "community" is transitory. If you move from the west end to the east end of Toronto everything looks and feels the same, but the people are different - but it doesn't matter. You still keep in touch with friends online.

As we move to greater short-term goals, we are more willing to do things that aren't in our own best interest. A salesman might close a deal he knows will be shutdown, only to be paid the commission this month rather than next month. The consensus is "money now is better than money later".

Three decades of failed leadership and the loss of national competition (vs. USSR) has created a political caste that is also completely self-interested. Their goal is not to accomplish something big, it is to accomplish enough to get re-elected. It is our politicians who are most to blame for failures of modern society and we need to look at ways to start over the political system.

Modern American economics is failing and without changes, the whole political system will collapse - what may follow it is unclear.

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

US Chronic Problems

Optimists argue that the global economy has merely hit a “soft patch.” Firms and consumers reacted to this year’s shocks by “temporarily” slowing consumption, capital spending, and job creation. As long as the shocks don’t worsen (and as some become less acute), confidence and growth will recover in the second half of the year, and stock markets will rally again.

Factors slowing US growth are chronic. These include slow but persistent private and public-sector deleveraging; rising oil prices; weak job creation; another downturn in the housing market; severe fiscal problems at the state and local level; and an unsustainable deficit and debt burden at the federal level.*

The financial crisis was driven by the multi-TRILLION dollar housing bust - until that is resolved (i.e. prices start increasing); this process of de-leveraging cannot complete. Banks must keep taking write downs (I would avoid bank stocks completely); the Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac issue needs to be addressed (billions/qtr in loses, still); and US consumers need to pay off their debts (a problem exacerbated by short sales).

Looking at post-housing bust Japan; the US is looking at the same medium-term issues that caused the Lost Decades. While the US stock market has recovered much more quickly and US banks were forced to write-down loses much, much sooner the comparison is still fair. We cannot rebuild trillions of dollars in lost wealth overnight.

With a $14 trillion GDP and 3% growth, we are adding $420 billion in wealth a year. Estimates vary, but loses from the financial crisis near $4.5 trillion, so even at 3% growth (higher than 1.8% in Q1 2011), it will take 10 years to rebuild the lost wealth.

The US economy is now larger than pre-crisis, which is a positive sign, but factoring in growth in the labour supply and population we are still well away from producing enough wealth to reduce the unemployment rate. We also need to understand that the debt, even at 2.96% rate, is a skim off the economy. Those interest payments (on $14 trillion), essentially wipe out the wealth creation and transfer to the foreign lenders. This is the danger of large deficits - it can turn into a vicious cycle.

*Credit to Nouriel Roubini for the initial insight.